Showing posts with label football slave trade. Show all posts
Showing posts with label football slave trade. Show all posts

Monday, February 23, 2009

Football Confidential

I just cracked a copy of Football Confidential (2000), an investigative documentary book from the BBC... "a journey through the underbelly of our (the UK's) national game covering the period when it transmuted from a mere spectator sport into an entertainment industry" (p6).

This is gonna be good. Here's a bit from chapter 10:
Soccer Slaves
The young players dumped on the streets by ruthless agents
Living in an abandoned bus, cold and hungry, wasn't exactly Timi had in mind when he was promised a glittering career in European football.

An engaging and articulate young man, he showed talent from the time he first kicked a ball as a seven-year-old on the streets of Lagos, the Nigerian capital. 'When I was young I always ed I'd play in Europe, especially in Germany or England," he says. "My father loved football. He encouraged me to play and, when I had the opportunity to go to Europe to further my career, he gave me the finance to go there.'

Timi (his full name is Adewusi Olurotimi) was 17 when a footballing friend put him in touch with an agent. 'The agent made me a lot of promises before I left Nigeria; and because I was a teenager I had to sign lots of papers for my parents saying that he was going to take care of me and find me a club. He said that if I came to Europe I would live better than in Nigeria, play football, be happy, gain a lot of money and play in a big club. I believed him.'

What happened next was just one example of a football scandal that is now being investigated at the highest levels of the United Nations. It is a story that stretches from the slums of Rio to the shanty towns of Soweto; a seedy, frightening saga of human trafficking and exploitation that borders on slavery. How could it happen at the dawn of the twenty-first century is testimony to the greed and opportunism of much of the modern game.

Saturday, February 21, 2009

Bikey of Reading FC talks about slave trade

One of the few players in European pro leagues that I've even heard talking publicly about the football slave trade, Andrey Bikey of Reading FC, originally Cameroon, is quoted in the Modern Ghana News, March 5, 2008:
“I never went to a football academy; I started playing at school and near my home. I played for a third-division team and it was only when I was selected for the Cameroon under-17 team that I started to take football seriously. During a tournament in Italy the Espanyol manager invited me to a trial; now I've played in Spain, Portugal, Moscow and England.

“Many European teams go to Africa to watch boys with a view to bringing them to their clubs. It used to be only a few players, but now, every year in Cameroon, many children are brought to Europe for trials. A lot of young players in Paris have nothing; they have come from Africa and if their trial doesn't go well they are left on the streets. Some agent will pick up the kid and take them to Europe, and if it doesn't work out they abandon them.

Young players in Africa do need more help and more attention.”
Not the most critical sentiment against the practice, but the only I've located from a star player.

Friday, February 20, 2009

Is the football slave trade "sticky"?

In continuing to think about whether the football slave trade controversy has a real public consciousness among football fans, I decided to start digging around on my current-favorite social networking site: Facebook! This morning, I joined a handful of facebook groups having to do with soccer in some way (e.g. some FIFA groups, team fansites for ManU, Arsenal, and Barca, and a smattering of others). Here's more or less what I've posted on the discussion boards:

Hi everyone, I have been doing research into what's been called the 'football slave trade' and I'm hoping people can help inform me. (see these links for some news stories on the issue... http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2008/02/09/1202234232502.html... http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/tv_and_radio/world_football/1695869.stm).

So here's my questions: do many football fans know about this controversy? How aware are you of it? Where did you hear or read about it? If you are aware of it, do you think it matters? Do you care? Do you feel anything could or should be done about it?

If you are willing to respond honestly--in any way you'd like--I'd be grateful.
Not sure if I'll get responses or what sort, but this might just help me understand whether or not this controversy is "sticky"?

Thursday, February 19, 2009

What makes a controversy stick?

Leigh got me thinking about this question yesterday...

So from the news that I've collected around the football slave trade (some of which I've posted to the blog), this story had some legs back in the early 2000's. Since then, the problem has evolved, becoming more entrenched and legitimatized. News stories continue to surface now and again, and more academics have investigated (but who reads academics anyway?), but is the 'slave trade' a controversy with broad public consciousness among football fans? Are people aware? Do they care? Do people simply feel impotent to do anything?

What does make a controversy stick -- or slip quietly into the background? What makes a social issue publicly salient, and gives it weight in the media-sphere?

Is Mikel's story a slave trade saga?

Interesting to me how this Irish Independent article framed Mikel John Obi within the contentious contract negotiations that took place between himself, Manchester United, & Chelsea FC back in 2005. Mikel, a major prospect from Nigeria, who supposedly made a deal to play with with Man U, later reneged and signed with Chelsea (Mikel's agent had close ties to Chelsea FC... wink wink, nudge nudge).

Sue Mott writes: "This is like the slave trade in reverse. Still imperialists invading Africa, and trafficking in human life, only the rewards are different. Slaves were ridiculously poor, footballers are ridiculously rich. But there is one similarity: loss of freedom."

Mott's distinction only holds up if you look at footballers who 'make it' at the top peofessional level. "Ridiculously rich" does not represent all footballers, not even a simple majority. Most do not make it, and do not have the social capital to negotiate ridiculously profitable contracts. But let's not get bogged down with attention to the little guy. We're talking about the stars here.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

exploring the trade

In response to critics of the so-called football slave trade -- and to European football clubs' history of accessing (and exploiting) cheap African talent -- one could say, Look, Europe is the world’s epicenter of pro football. It's where the most competitive play occurs, where the most profitable leagues flourish, where players receive the most lucrative contracts. It should come as no surprise to anyone that young athletes around the world dream of growing up and playing for Barça, Arsenal, Manchester United, Marseille... or that many of them would go to extreme means for the opportunity to make it. This point I concede freely. But what is deeply troubling is the route by which most African boys must travel in hopes of making it in the European leagues.

Pro teams go scouring for potential talent that can be signed on the super-cheap. Pro agents prowl the streets of Accra and Abijan, hoping to “poach” the next star player. Community football coaches and managers, and even parents, hoping to get rich off children. As Dan McDougall (2008) has put it:
European, Arab and increasingly West African middlemen are effectively buying the best young players from their families in tightly binding contracts, often backed up by threats of violence against families with the hope of making a small fortune selling the boys onto the West or extorting their families for the cost of passage.
As young as 10 years old, these young boys are sold into lop-sided contractual obligations, shipped off to Europe, and set on course in football training programs. Tens of thousands of players have passed through this gauntlet. For the majority of these young men, their chances do not materialize into professional contracts and are shown the door, frequently left on the streets of European cities, as undocumented, “illegal” immigrants. In the worst-case scenarios, these kids have entered into child prostitution to survive (Donnelly & Petherick, 2004). In 2001, FIFA responded with new regulations, preventing clubs from signing players under 18 years, and creating policies whereby clubs outside of Europe that manage the football training and formation of players under 18 receive compensation from any European club that signs one of its player (FIFA, cited in Darby, 2007). Yet at the same time that regulations were being constructed, this transnational, peculiar institution was already in motion, constructing a new system to circumvent the regulations, and thus, continue the flow of cheap labor from Africa to Europe. The establishment of African football academies has boomed since that time, legal and illegal "schools" that even can capitalize on FIFA regulations.

So, in what ways do 'football academies' provide the legal cover for the maintenance of this modern-day slave trade? How does race, ethnicity, and class operate within this complex? Who benefits? Who suffers? What social theories (do/can) emerge from this complex "from or on behalf of historically oppressed groups (to) invest ways to escape from, survive in, and/or oppose prevailing social and economic injuststice?" (Hills Collins, 1998, xiii) This last question in particular will be critical to my inquiries...
more as it comes.

Friday, February 13, 2009

Tainted Dreams

Sydney Morning Herald, February 10, 2008

They dream of glory, but too often Africa's football hopefuls end up on the streets of Europe.
Dan McDougall's investigative report.

Belgium's Football Slave Trade

BBC Sport Online: Friday, 7 December, 2001

Richard Fleming discusses the illegal exploitation of black footballers forced to play for nothing in Belgium.

New Slave Trade

3/19/2008, New Criminologist
Joss Haynes has a concise article on the trafficking of youth between Africa and Europe. Referring to what's been dubbed 'the football slave trade,' FIFA president has railed against European football clubs for committing “social and economical rape,” and has called the scores of illegal agents “false prophets” who prey on and exploit families and children that get lured in by (usually) empty promises and the dreams of success.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

a broad stroked "problem"

As early human records show, civilizations have played games, acting upon people’s desires to compete—and to be victorious. Societies have been captivated by athletes, their skillful performances, and the contentious battles they wage within the sporting arena. For example, the Mayan people played Pok-a-tok, a game on a stone court with sloped walls and stone rings hung high that served as goalposts. Pok-a-tok was filled with ritual, religious, and mythological significance; its winners treated as heroes, its losers facing harsh penalties, even human sacrifice, a practice that was thought necessary for the peoples' continued health and prosperity. The Greeks had their games that also carried great cultural importance, as did the Romans, and scores of civilizations throughout history. In fact, we could trace any society’s histories of sport, and understand something about its social order, and about that society’s connections between the physical body, power, knowledge, and social management.

Yet within the 20th Century, we witness the rise of a new cultural phenomenon: the sport-industrial complex (SIC), a complex, adaptive system that cultural critic Dave Zirin calls " a sprawling, overly influential industry that has impacted all of our lives," whether we like it or not. The SIC (like the military-industrial complex and the prison-industrial complex) exists not as a secret conspiracy, but rather, as a network of bureaucratic, political, and economic interests that encourages spending on professional sports to advance particular agendas . Consisting of private businesses and corporations that regard professional sports as a vast and profitable market, politicians who saber for public investment in pro franchises, and local communities that count on sports to sustain the local economy, to name a few, this vast global network implicates all of us in some ways.

I realize I am painting this "problem", or socio-dynamic, in broad strokes. I do promise to hone in and to illustrate an argument by localizing the problem/s, but for now, please allow me to continue casting a wide net... So connected to my research with Hargreaves in the sectors of education, business, and sport, I have begun playing with questions related to the interactions and effects of professional sports organizations across communities. I am curious about the diverse ways that these sport organizations, which operate as for-profit businesses and corporations, transact with the communities that they are linked. Within this, I have a particular interest in how youth are impacted and implicated.

First, a bit on what I mean by ‘communities.’ This can refer to the locale that hosts the pro team. For instance, the city of Paris hosts several pro football (soccer) clubs, one being Paris Saint-Germain F.C. (PSG), whose training grounds are just outside Paris and stadium, in the uber-wealthy 16th arrondissement of the city. PSG, its worth estimated around 41 million euros (BBC News, 2006), receives substantial support from Paris’ municipal government in the form of subsidies, financial incentives, and public services offered. Public support for these subsidies stems, though not exclusively, from expectations that the host community will reap certain economic and social benefits.

At the same time, current PSG players hail from communities in France, Brazil, Benin, Mali, Serbia, the Republic of Congo, Armenia, and Cameroon. PSG, as well as Paris and French society more generally, are connected to each of these communities in similar and dissimilar ways. Historically, France established and operated colonies in four of these respective nations. In our post-colonial (neocolonial?) world, in what ways can we hear any echoes of the past? Somewhat recently, investigative journalists began reporting on what has been called the ‘football slave trade’ (e.g. BBC News, 2000), whereby pro football agents travel abroad in the hope of “poaching” young talent in African and other developing nations. The teams are looking for the next star players that can be signed on the cheap. The young boys, some of them reported to be 15 years old, dream of the opportunity to play in the European leagues, and frequently enter into contractual obligations that are not in their interests. Families have been given significant cash loans in exchange for the rights to represent their son, loans that then can sink the family into deep debt and leave the athlete bound to the agent’s company. And if the player cannot hack it in the pro’s, they are shown the door, now displaced from their home community and usually without working papers. It can be said that social and racial formations from the past can be seen in present-day circumstances (Collins, 2005).

I am open to a number of research angles at this point, and am just getting my feet into the literature. I feel like I need, to some degree, to wait and see where it leads me. My rough intent would be to conduct a sociological case study on 1 pro sport organization (or possibly 2?), to examine its interactions with and impacts across communities--and with youth, in particular. I see this project, like my weird little brain, as a theoretical hybrid, drawing on historical perspectives, structural-economic research, critical pedagogy, postcolonial studies, political science, philosophy, pop culture... To start--embedded within this inquiry are matters of power--in Foucault's (1980) words: "What are the various contrivances of power, whose operations extend to such differing levels and sectors of society and are possessed of such manifold ramifications? What are their mechanisms, their effects and their relations?" (p.88).

Citations:
  • BBC News (2000, Feb. 14). Africa’s football ‘slave trade.’ Accessed online at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/639390.stm
  • BBC News (2006, April 11). Paris Saint-Germain changes hands. Accessed online at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/4898746.stm
  • Collins, P.H. (2005). Black Sexual Politics. Taylor and Francis.
  • Foucault (1980). Power/Knowledge.
  • Zirin, D. (2007). Welcome to the terrordome: The pain, politics, and promise of sports. Chicago: Haymarket Books.