Showing posts with label questions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label questions. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

a broad stroked "problem"

As early human records show, civilizations have played games, acting upon people’s desires to compete—and to be victorious. Societies have been captivated by athletes, their skillful performances, and the contentious battles they wage within the sporting arena. For example, the Mayan people played Pok-a-tok, a game on a stone court with sloped walls and stone rings hung high that served as goalposts. Pok-a-tok was filled with ritual, religious, and mythological significance; its winners treated as heroes, its losers facing harsh penalties, even human sacrifice, a practice that was thought necessary for the peoples' continued health and prosperity. The Greeks had their games that also carried great cultural importance, as did the Romans, and scores of civilizations throughout history. In fact, we could trace any society’s histories of sport, and understand something about its social order, and about that society’s connections between the physical body, power, knowledge, and social management.

Yet within the 20th Century, we witness the rise of a new cultural phenomenon: the sport-industrial complex (SIC), a complex, adaptive system that cultural critic Dave Zirin calls " a sprawling, overly influential industry that has impacted all of our lives," whether we like it or not. The SIC (like the military-industrial complex and the prison-industrial complex) exists not as a secret conspiracy, but rather, as a network of bureaucratic, political, and economic interests that encourages spending on professional sports to advance particular agendas . Consisting of private businesses and corporations that regard professional sports as a vast and profitable market, politicians who saber for public investment in pro franchises, and local communities that count on sports to sustain the local economy, to name a few, this vast global network implicates all of us in some ways.

I realize I am painting this "problem", or socio-dynamic, in broad strokes. I do promise to hone in and to illustrate an argument by localizing the problem/s, but for now, please allow me to continue casting a wide net... So connected to my research with Hargreaves in the sectors of education, business, and sport, I have begun playing with questions related to the interactions and effects of professional sports organizations across communities. I am curious about the diverse ways that these sport organizations, which operate as for-profit businesses and corporations, transact with the communities that they are linked. Within this, I have a particular interest in how youth are impacted and implicated.

First, a bit on what I mean by ‘communities.’ This can refer to the locale that hosts the pro team. For instance, the city of Paris hosts several pro football (soccer) clubs, one being Paris Saint-Germain F.C. (PSG), whose training grounds are just outside Paris and stadium, in the uber-wealthy 16th arrondissement of the city. PSG, its worth estimated around 41 million euros (BBC News, 2006), receives substantial support from Paris’ municipal government in the form of subsidies, financial incentives, and public services offered. Public support for these subsidies stems, though not exclusively, from expectations that the host community will reap certain economic and social benefits.

At the same time, current PSG players hail from communities in France, Brazil, Benin, Mali, Serbia, the Republic of Congo, Armenia, and Cameroon. PSG, as well as Paris and French society more generally, are connected to each of these communities in similar and dissimilar ways. Historically, France established and operated colonies in four of these respective nations. In our post-colonial (neocolonial?) world, in what ways can we hear any echoes of the past? Somewhat recently, investigative journalists began reporting on what has been called the ‘football slave trade’ (e.g. BBC News, 2000), whereby pro football agents travel abroad in the hope of “poaching” young talent in African and other developing nations. The teams are looking for the next star players that can be signed on the cheap. The young boys, some of them reported to be 15 years old, dream of the opportunity to play in the European leagues, and frequently enter into contractual obligations that are not in their interests. Families have been given significant cash loans in exchange for the rights to represent their son, loans that then can sink the family into deep debt and leave the athlete bound to the agent’s company. And if the player cannot hack it in the pro’s, they are shown the door, now displaced from their home community and usually without working papers. It can be said that social and racial formations from the past can be seen in present-day circumstances (Collins, 2005).

I am open to a number of research angles at this point, and am just getting my feet into the literature. I feel like I need, to some degree, to wait and see where it leads me. My rough intent would be to conduct a sociological case study on 1 pro sport organization (or possibly 2?), to examine its interactions with and impacts across communities--and with youth, in particular. I see this project, like my weird little brain, as a theoretical hybrid, drawing on historical perspectives, structural-economic research, critical pedagogy, postcolonial studies, political science, philosophy, pop culture... To start--embedded within this inquiry are matters of power--in Foucault's (1980) words: "What are the various contrivances of power, whose operations extend to such differing levels and sectors of society and are possessed of such manifold ramifications? What are their mechanisms, their effects and their relations?" (p.88).

Citations:
  • BBC News (2000, Feb. 14). Africa’s football ‘slave trade.’ Accessed online at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/639390.stm
  • BBC News (2006, April 11). Paris Saint-Germain changes hands. Accessed online at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/4898746.stm
  • Collins, P.H. (2005). Black Sexual Politics. Taylor and Francis.
  • Foucault (1980). Power/Knowledge.
  • Zirin, D. (2007). Welcome to the terrordome: The pain, politics, and promise of sports. Chicago: Haymarket Books.

Saturday, February 7, 2009

Casting a wide net

Choosing to start broadly, I figured I need to ask, What does the literature {e.g. theoretical research, empirical research, policy papers, evaluation studies, news & popular press, company websites, ...} in the fields of sport, business, education, and community development say about the role of professional sports organizations within community relations/community engagement/public relations?

As a clarifying point, at this moment I'm interested in more direct forms of engagement, not so much in indirect forms, like social-issues ad campaigns or PSA's.

So last week, I began by combing through the stacks of Boston College and Boston University libraries, skimming books related to sports in society. Over several days, I lugged bags of books home and to the office, books on the economic dynamics of pro sports, like Pay Dirt, on the sociology of sports, on cultural representations in pro sports (for example, why we look upon sport stars as deities, where this tradition stems from), and a few textbooks on sports management. Plus, I've got a list of 10 books or so in O'Neill stacks just waiting for me to release them from their shelves and stack on mine.

Next, I've begun running searches in the social sciences CrossSearch, a search engine that cuts across multiple databases:
Anthropology Plus, Communication Abstracts, ERIC, Linguistics and Language Behavior Abstracts, PsycARTICLES, PsycINFO 1840-current, Social Sciences Citation Index, Social Services Abstracts, and Sociological Abstracts. So far, I have found very little that directly addresses my question, but a lot of material to contextualize things.

I know the task of familiarizing myself with a wide body of literature will be long (and I've only started), and the next step of tightening my gaze seems like so foreign at this point, but my early sense is that this is a ripe area for inquiry. Many researchers and writers have delved into the complicated relationships of professional sports in society, yet few authors appear to have directly approached the pedagogical relationships therein.
More to come...

Friday, February 6, 2009

My questions, as they stand

First, a bit of background: this year, I've gotten involved in a relatively large-scale international study exploring leadership and change within high-performing organizations (following a slump or near-failure of the organization) across 4 sectors--education, business, sports, and health. Entitled, Performing Beyond Expectations (PBE), this is will mostly be a "good news" story, trying to understand what kinds of leadership decisions and actions were taken within the organization and how they contributed to the org.'s turnaround and sustained performance.

Connected to this, I've begun muddling around questions about the role(s) of professional sports organizations within community-based education, with a particular eye towards youth-related issues (I may want to first delimit this more broadly, as community engagement..??). Through my involvement in PBE, I have access to pro sports teams in the U.K. and soon, hopefully, in the US. My current plan is to examine various pro clubs' patterns of engagement with their local communities, as well as the multiple Discourses (ideologies) that are recruited to do the sociocultural lifting, so to speak. How do these Discourses operate, and to what ends? In what ways do they 'rub up against one another'? Embedded within are matters of power--in Foucault's words: "What are the various contrivances of power, whose operations extend to such differing levels and sectors of society and are possessed of such manifold ramifications? What are their mechanisms, their effects and their relations?" (Power/Knowledge, 1980, p.88)

These are questions I need to ask in beginning to unravel (and inevitably re-entangle) the complex interplay between professional sports, civil society, the government, and education.